Friday, February 1, 2008

Atheistic Dogmatism?

I am trying to understand how atheistic belief can be dogmatic about the assertion that God does not exist. I can understand someone saying "I am not convinced that God exists". To say something absolutely doesn't exist because it has never been experienced seems irrational, especially if many others have witnessed to the experience. For example, can someone say with certainty that a pink flying elephant does not exist anywhere in the universe? Not unless that person has been everywhere in the universe. But one can say that they doubt it exists and have seen no convincing evidence that it does. I wonder if many who call themselves atheists are actually agnostic, or if I just don’t understand atheistic belief adequately.

I notice that atheists tend to have faith in science and intellect. To believe that science holds all the answers is to have a belief in science as the source of all truth. It also seems to infer that there is no truth other than that discoverable through science. The scientific approach is very useful, but to think it alone can provide absolute truth for all aspects of human life seems unreasonable. It is based upon the reasoning abilities of humans, which are not always reliable. If humans are the source of absolute truth through the application of their intellect, this seems to imply that humans are "God". So if we are our own "God" our point of reference is ourselves, which seems comparable to a ship using itself for navigation rather than a star or lighthouse. It also seems limiting, like if we only used chemistry as a discipline for discovery. We would miss out on that knowledge obtainable through physics or other scientific disciplines.

I relate using our intellect for proof that our own intellect is the source of truth to the circular argument that the Bible is inspired because it says it is inspired. I believe the Bible is inspired. However, the fact it says so is not the reason to believe. To say that truth is only discoverable through our intellect because our intellect tells us that truth is only discoverable through our intellect also seems circular.

I am not attempting to be argumentative or engage in pointless debate – I am convinced that people will believe what they want to believe regardless of the evidence or lack thereof. I do want to understand the atheistic viewpoint and hopefully spur consideration among atheists that God may possibly exist. Ultimately my goal is not to try to prove I am right and someone else is wrong, or that Christians are better people than non-Christians. (“Christ came not to make bad people good but to make dead people live”). My goal is to get people to consider that God may exist and that possibly the story of Christ is true, so that they will investigate further and share in the experience I have had by accepting the love of God through Christ. I do not proclaim Christianity to be true because it seems to make the most sense compared to other belief systems, but because it made sense AND I experienced the love and peace from God confirming its truth.

If eternal life is at all possible, doesn’t it make sense to seek it at all costs rather than dismiss it due to intellectual arrogance? Please do not take offense at that statement. Many (I would say most) atheists have very keen intellects. But it seems many think that their intellect is infallible, when it is not for any of us.

When you have something clearly in your hand, sometimes you can be talked out of believing that you have it through intellectual argument. The logic may seem correct, but somehow it is flawed because you really do have it. I say this because that happened to me regarding my faith in Christ. I knew I had eternal life but then was convinced intellectually that I didn’t. It took me a while to realize the folly of my own intellectual arrogance. There is more to being human than raw intellect.

Any clarification to help my understanding would be appreciated.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

One reason NOT to use to disregard atheism or theism

Something I hear repeated often is the statement that religion is the cause of about all the evil that has occured in the world. However, consider this: the largest abuses of mankind in the 20th century occured under non-religious governments. Germany under Hitler, Soviet Union under Stalin, to mention a couple.

That doesn't mean that religious governments and authorities are innocent. What it does mean is that religion is not the common factor here. What is common? Governments and authorities are human institutions. The problem is not religion or atheism, it is Man. Mankind is capable of great evil, as well as great good.

My point is that religious belief should not be invalidated due to the abuses caused by the nature of Man. If you consider the historical record, I do not believe that one can assert atheism will produce a better result. Neither can you invalidate atheism on the same basis. What is the real issue? Going with the premise that mankind is capable of performing "evil" acts (evil meaning destructive behavior), I believe there are two questions - 1. Should this problem be dealt with at all? 2. If so, what is the root cause and how do we eliminate it?

As you can tell from my previous post ("fyi" on 1/2/08), I consider that the root cause is that explained by Christianity. In general, it provides a remedy for evil behavior. This is not a reason to believe in Christ as a personal savior, although it is a reason to follow Christ's teachings. This will produce a benefit to mankind as a whole, but for the individual the payoff is in not only following Christ's teachings, but in taking advantage of the offer of a resurrection from death in a form that will no longer have a nature that produces evil results. Imagine if you could live among people who do no evil, and to whom no evil occurs. You might call that "heaven".

Please let me know if I am not thinking about this issue correctly, or if you agree that abuses are not a reason to disregard religious belief or non-belief - that we need to look at other factors.